Correction: Ouma Shu Had the Worst Christmas

(This post is part of a series of posts covering Christmas-themed anime episodes. For more posts like these, check out the 12 Days of Anime tag.)

If I thought Kirito had a crap Christmas, Ouma Shu of Guilty Crown fame blows his suffering out of the water. The Lost Christmas in Guilty Crown involved Ouma Shu getting sexually harassed by his yandere older sister and a whole city of people dying in the apocalypse. Can’t get much worse than that!


Guilty Crown isn’t a terribly good show by any stretch of the imagination. Like Sword Art Online, it’s an anime that bloggers love to hate, but besides a string of really silly episodes (the Nazi Shu arc comes to mind), Guilty Crown was never anything other than middling. In fact, when I got around to rewatching episode 12 to write this post, I found I’d forgotten almost everything that happened in the story.

Episode 12 is dense with content to the point of incoherence, but it is a significant point in the Guilty Crown narrative for a number of reasons. Firstly, it’s the climax of the first half of the story. It’s chock-a-block with dramatic reveals, including an extended flashback into Shu and Gai’s shared past. Secondly, it’s quite possibly the episode I stopped taking Guilty Crown seriously, even if I never thought of it as particularly good. Everything about Mana’s character is ridiculous, but she was the best part of the episode. Mana allowed me to embrace the inherent stupidity of this story’s setup.


From what I understand, Gai loves Mana for saving his life, while Mana wants to marry her brother because this is an anime. Okay, so far so good. I can understand this logic, at least.

Then Mana tricks Gai into shooting himself because… because… why the fuck not? After that, she puts on Gai’s blood as lipstick and assumes this will somehow get her into her brother’s pants. A winning plan, only foiled by Shu’s lack of sex drive.

Dr. Aggle sums it up:

It turns out that Lost Christmas happened and the world was nearly destroyed because Shuu wasn’t a siscon. It’s all his fault.

Let this lesson be learned.

Anyway, as Shu is angsting over the fact that everyone suddenly died (except for him, because he is shielded by plot armour), Gai appears out of nowhere with barely a wound on him even though he recently shot himself. Instead of trying to comfort Shu or suggest they work together to work out what the hell just happened, he just says, “I have to get stronger,” and disappears mysteriously, never to be seen again for years.

As you can see, it’s not the most well thought out of backstories. It’s hard to feel the tragedy when none of these characters make sense or are particularly likable. Mana does stand out for being batshit insane, though. Perhaps this is why the fact that millions of people died as a result of Mana’s raging libido amused me instead of saddened me.

Another thing I’m grateful to Guilty Crown and Lost Christmas for is that it introduced me to anime blogs. At the time I only knew three anime blogs: Star-Crossed Anime Blog, Shinmaru’s blog (which is a dead blog now) and Draggle’s blog. But I had a heap of fun listening to the Guilty Crown singalongs and voting for the dumbest moment every week. Thank you, Guilty Crown, for introducing me to the light!


  1. I’m quite convinced Shuu was too ??? at all the incoherence to suffer much. You absolutely cannot compare this show with SAO. Like Kawahara’s writing or not, he’s one person writing a sensible story. This had several scriptwriters on the job, and I really, really doubt they ever met up to make sure they were writing the same story.

  2. Yeah its also because of this episode that i stopped caring about this shows logic. Its also why i feel indifferent when Gai somehow came back to live….

  3. Oh god I remember this golden moment. I never figured out what the hell the creators were thinking with this crappy written and executed episode.

  4. See, it’s things like this make me sad I didn’t get into fandom sooner. That sounds like so much fun! Shows like Guilty Crown bring out the best in people. I’m glad bad anime like that exist

  5. I have an unnaturally high tolerance for bullshit but Guilty Crown really gave me a run for my money. Now that I no longer remember much about the plot, re-reading parts of it feels even more ridiculous.

    • Yep! I lurked around for a while afterwards, but Guilty Crown was the show that got me interested in reading anime blogs. I’m not sure I would have even finished Guilty Crown in the first place if it wasn’t for you guys *sniff*

  6. I loved Mana in Guilty Crown. She’s insane and wants to not only marry her brother, but create a new race of people with him. Guilty Crown may be remembered for a lot of bad moments, but I’ll always thank it for introducing me to Mana.

  7. I actually only just watched Guilty Crown for the first time a few months ago – I ended up trying it out to satisfy my curiosity after seeing so many people hating on it. I was vaguely disappointed that it felt so remarkably average after all that fuss though; people were making it sound like it was the worst thing they had ever laid eyes on, when in fact it didn’t strike me as being particularly outstanding either way. (I did quite like the first OP though.)

    • Guilty Crown was one of those shows where the reactions were far more entertaining than the show itself.

      The first OP is great, though. I absolutely adore the song.

    • That’ because GC was considered the peak of terribad anime back then, but after watching productions like Samurai flamenco, Valvrape and cross Ange the following years, Guilty Crown, sadly, doesn’t looks so ridiculous anymore

      • *shrugs* I haven’t watched either Vavlrave or Cross Ange, but I quite liked Samurai Flamenco. In any case, people can compare anime to each other until the cows come home and rate them accordingly, and I’m not saying that’s inherently a bad thing, but I prefer to try and rate anime more on their own, individual terms.

Leave a Reply to Projectnoa Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s